Sex and Doctors: why young men don't go PDF Print E-mail
Written by Kate Jongbloed   
Wednesday, 12 August 2009 00:00
Digg!
Del.icio.us!
Google!
Live!
Facebook!
StumbleUpon!
Tags: teen - sex - health - planned parenthood - survey - youth - desire

One of the greatest stereotypes about men is that they hate going to the doctor, especially when it comes to sex.  The recent Toronto Teen Survey on sexual health backs this up: in Toronto, young women are twice as likely to access sexual health services than men.  What’s the story here?

In general, Toronto youth aren’t accessing sexual health care.  The survey, which included more than 1200 teens from all around the city, shows that 83 percent of youth have never visited a clinic or doctor for any sexual health reason.  This included 42 percent of sexually active youth.

This is an issue because in Canada, sexually transmitted infection (STI) rates are highest among youth aged 15-19, and in Toronto rates for chlamydia, gonorrhea and syphillis have been on the rise since 2001.  These increasing rates of STIs are a sign of potential increases in HIV incidence among Canadian youth. To reverse this trend, young men and women need better sex ed and more visits to sexual health services.

So why the gender divide?  Can we just chalk it up to “men don’t like going to the doctor,” or is there something more here?


The survey gives a few hints at why young women are way more likely than young men to seek out sexual health services.  For one, there’s the pull of The Pill: young women look for birth control, pap smears and pregnancy tests, while young men go for free condoms, information about safer sex and HIV, or STI testing.  And, in general, young women rated their experience with sexual health services more highly than young men – if your experience is better, you’re more likely to go again or recommend the service to a friend.  As well, according to the service providers included in the survey reasons for youth not accessing services include:

  • feeling invincible
  • waiting to seek service for treatment rather than prevention
  • lack of awareness of existing services, and
  • stigma around sex in some communities

Another clue comes from what youth told the survey they wanted to know about sexual health but weren’t learning.  Healthy relationships, HIV/AIDS and sexual pleasure are the top three sexual health topics youth want to learn about.  Or, as Dr. Peggy Kleinplatz puts it, adolescents want “information about being a partner, rather than only about the health of the genitals. ”In other words, it seems like we sometimes forget about desire.

As well, youth in the survey didn't feel that clinics were youth friendly and they worried about judgement by friends, parents and clinic staff, and confidentiality.  In response, Planned Parenthood Toronto put together a Youth Bill of Sexual Health Care Rights, which explains 10 rights young people already have but may not know about.  They are also working with sexual health service providers to better meet the needs of youth.


Maybe if sexual health is seen as "more than just limiting disease and unintended pregnancy" and youth know their sexual health care rights, we'll see more young men in waiting rooms around the city being proactive about their health and that of their partner.

Most of the information presented here can be found in Sarah Flicker, Susan Flynn, June Larkin, Rob Travers, Adrian Guta, Jason Pole, and Crystal Layne (2009) Sexpress: The Toronto Teen Survey Report.  Planned Parenthood Toronto.  Toronto, ON.

youth bill of sexual health care rights

 

*********

Kate is an international health and development writer with a passion for technology, health equity, and innovation.  She blogs weekly at unpackingdevelopment.com

Last Updated on Wednesday, 12 August 2009 12:57
 
Comments
Add New Search
+/-
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Title:
 
Security Image
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
Zahra  - Would like to see more of this   |38.99.179.xxx |2009-08-26 07:15:28
Just wanted to make a note that this study seems to be identifying something that needs to be further explored. It's fascinating and if developed further, could cause significant change. Congratulations to Toronto Teen Survey and Plan Parenthood for some great work.
Dan  - How can health care serve men better?   |70.81.33.xxx |2009-08-17 12:55:15
This is the question we should be asking. Not, "How can we convince men do go to the doctor" or "Why are men too macho to seek help." Medical schools, doctors and society at large need to take a close look at the culture and discourse around medicine (healing, sacrifice, etc.) and figure out why men are feeling alienated. Men don't avoid doctors because they choose not to take care of themselves. They avoid doctors because, it seems, our health care system hasn't figured out how to take care of them.
paulbaines  - not convinced   |SAdministrator |2009-08-19 08:29:47
hi dan, i agree with not trying to 'convince' men to go to the doctor...but why just look at the 'culture and discourse' around medicine and not masculinity?
i agree that men want to take care of themselves, but isn't that care shaped by 'how' they see themselves (gender roles and assumptions and all) when it comes to health? if being macho is at odds with seeking help, how can the health care system (solely?) address this? what role do men have in maintaining these separations?
taniak  - reasons for care?   |99.253.214.xxx |2009-08-26 13:54:38
This article definitely provides food for thought! In reading it, I kept thinking if I were to pass this on to the youth (ages 13-18) in my youth leadership programs, what would they say? In putting myself in their shoes, I realized that they would ask, "as young men what kinds of sexual care should we be asking for? There's nothing more than free condoms and a blood test that we should be going for, isn't there?!?" Obviously we know all the ones females can receive (and they were clearly listed in the article: birth control, pap smear, pregnancy tests, and not to mention mammograms and ultrasounds) but what would a young man go to a sex (health) clinic for? I think these (hypothetical) questions would be important indicators of how little young men are educated/aware of what sexual health issues they should be looking out for, and what the causes and consequences of lack of early detection/treatment are. Unless this knowledge is provided to young men on a mass scale - the same way birth control, mammograms, pap smears and more are advertised/encouraged for women, they won't see any reason to go. I would also agree with Paulbaines that the reason young men don't go to doctors (generally speaking) goes beyond the limitations of the medical system (although this is a valid point) and that it reflects the gender roles, male culture,and assumptions about masculinity that we have in society. Once we remove the barriers that these roles restrict each gender to (including men) we can look forward to a society where both males and females willingly and equally access health care.
Kate J  - Good question   |24.82.134.xxx |2009-08-26 13:52:07
This is exactly one of the questions asked by the Toronto Teen Survey and what Planned Parenthood is now working on implementing with service providers.

According to the survey, young men's top 5 wants from sexual health services in Toronto are: good info, location, comfortable asking questions, confidential, and non-judgemental. (see the full survey report for more details).

One of their close partners around change on this issue is the Gendering Adolescent AIDS Prevention Program (GAAP): http://www.utoronto.ca/iwsgs/GAAP/index.html

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

login to masc